I read this book for the Back
to the Classics Challenge 2021.
A 19th
Century Classic. I like literary criticism written by novelists. For
instance, I always liked George Orwell better as a critic than a novelist. On
his advice, I’ve read Smollet,
Shaw (here
and here),
and Ernest
Bramah. See the classic essay Good
Bad Books. Also, I read The Good Companions by J.B. Priestley and Gone to Earth by Mary Webb because they were mentioned in Roald Dahl's Matilda.
The English
Humourists of the Eighteenth Century - William Makepeace Thackeray
This collects six lectures on 1) Swift; 2) Congreve and
Addison; 3) Steele; 4) Prior, Gay, and Pope; 5) Hogarth, Smollett, and
Fielding; and 6) Sterne and Goldsmith. Thackeray respects his forbearers. It’s clear he did his homework while preparing for these
talks. He read the works of the subjects, old newspapers and magazines, memoirs
and collections of anecdotes.
Thackeray excels in the judicious quotation from the
works. From Addison in the Spectator:
I have always preferred
cheerfulness to mirth. The latter I consider as an act, the former as an habit
of the mind. Mirth is short and transient, cheerfulness fixed and permanent.
Those are often raised into the greatest transports of mirth who are subject to
the greatest depression of melancholy: on the contrary, cheerfulness, though it
does not give the mind such an exquisite gladness, prevents it from falling
into any depths of sorrow. Mirth is like a flash of lightning that breaks
through a gloom of clouds, and glitters for a moment; cheerfulness keeps up a
kind of daylight in the mind, and fills it with a steady and perpetual
serenity.
Marvelous that cheerfulness can be as dauntless as
courage. What a great way to look at cheerfulness, as a virtue perhaps not up
there wisdom and endurance but a good things to cultivate ue nevertheless like sympathy and relish
of life.
Even some footnotes are hilarious:
Besides these famous books of
Scott's and Johnson's, there is a copious Life
by Thomas Sheridan (Dr. Johnson's “Sherry”), father of Richard Brinsley, and
son of that good-natured, clever, Irish Doctor, Thomas Sheridan, Swift's
intimate, who lost his chaplaincy by so unluckily choosing for a text on the
king's birthday, “Sufficient for the day is the evil thereof!”
As for his criticism, he doesn’t have a theory and
sometimes he’s didactic. But he does have an orientation that values ethics and literary taste.
when Mr. Punch, that godless old
rebel, breaks every law and laughs at it with odious triumph, outwits his lawyer,
bullies the beadle, knocks his wife about the head, and hangs the hangman—don't
you see in the comedy, in the song, in the dance, in the ragged little Punch's
puppet-show—the Pagan protest? Doesn't it seem as if Life puts in its plea and
sings its comment? Look how the lovers walk and hold each other's hands and
whisper! Sings the chorus—“There is nothing like love, there is nothing like
youth, there is nothing like beauty of your spring-time. Look! how old age
tries to meddle with merry sport! Beat him with his own crutch, the wrinkled
old dotard! There is nothing like youth, there is nothing like beauty, there is
nothing like strength. Strength and valour win beauty and youth. Be brave and
conquer. Be young and happy. Enjoy, enjoy, enjoy! Would you know the segreto per esser felice (it’s better to
laugh than be sighing)? Here it is, in a smiling mistress and a cup of
Falernian.” As the boy tosses the cup and sings his song—hark! what is that
chaunt coming nearer and nearer? What is that dirge which will disturb us? The lights of the festival burn dim—the cheeks
turn pale—the voice quavers—and the cup drops on the floor. Who's there? Death
and Fate are at the gate, and they will
come in.
Maybe it’s the pandemic talking, but I find the run-up to that last
sentence superb. Yes, they will come in.
Besides readers like me who habitually mine all the books
they read lately for nuggets to deal with everything that’s going on now, who
will read Thackeray’s appreciations of his – and Dickens’ and Trollope’s -
forebears? Hardcore readers who are seriously into the 18th century
will deeply enjoy this. Though a sensitive Victorian in most ways, Thackeray
had a nostalgia for the rough, gamy 18th century. He brings to life
everyday life in Queen Anne’s time – travel, banquets, fast noblemen. Wonderful
stuff to take us away from virus, distancing, N95, diagnostics, stay at home, zoom, PPE, community spread, mask slackers and the vaccine ignorant.