I read this
for the 2014 War Challenge with a
Twist at the reading challenge blog War Through the Generations
Hollow
Victory: A Contrary View of the Gulf War - Jeffrey Record, 1993
This book about the war against
Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait was written to counter the self-congratulatory
euphoria
after the brief fighting and one-sided victory. Although Record is a “inside
the Beltway” military expert, having served as a Congressional aide, he is also
a professor and journalist and thus more open to facts and resistant to
partisan opinions. His thesis is straight-forward:
The Gulf War was a
magnificent military victory barren of any significant diplomatic gains. It was
fought to repel Saddam Hussein's challenge to the old order in the Persian Gulf,
not to create a new one. Accordingly, future historians may regard the war as a
complete failure.
This book is comprehensive, because the author has read all the
contemporary reportage in the Washington Post and New York time. A scholar, he has read the relevant
political, military, and strategic books too.
He seems to feel the war ended
too quickly and it was a mistake to leave Saddam in power, but he also grants the constraint on the Coalition since the U.N. mandate
did not include the invasion and occupation of Iraq. Note that this book was
written in 1993. It makes brief nods toward Islamic fundamentalism and
sectarianism. He was more concerned about Saddam’s capacity to build weapons of
mass destruction.
The tone is temperate and
skeptical. The writing style jams many appositive phrases and adjective clauses
so the alert reader must go slow, keeping on eye on subjects and predicates.
The book is not long, but contains much food for thought, especially in light of the fallout of Bushcheney's war of choice.
Thanks for your thoughts on this book. Sadly, I know so little about the Gulf Wars, but I like the idea that this one is comprehensive, though the writing style may not be my taste.
ReplyDeleteThanks for participating in the challenge! We hope you'll add this review to the Gulf War linky here:
http://warthroughthegenerations.wordpress.com/2014/01/06/gulf-wars-gulf-waroperation-desert-storm-and-iraq-waroperation-iraqi-freedom-review-linky/
I do feel that the atmosphere immediately after the first war was congratulatory. And the second war really comes to mind when thinking about how the first ended so quickly. I still wonder whether either should have occurred in the first place.
ReplyDelete