I read this book for the Mount
TBR 2018 Reading Challenge.
The Case of the
Black-eyed Blonde – Erle Stanley Gardner
“The lawyer is like a doctor,” says ace lawyer Perry
Mason to his PA Della Street, “only for justice.”
Perry Mason sees a gamut of iffy clients in his office -
but Diana Regis is probably one of the strangest. She arrives in the famous
attorney’s office clad only in a fur coat and a dressing gown, besides the
shiner of the title. It turns out that she was on a date she had been pressured
into – with her employer’s stepson. When she refused the stepson’s advances,
with an impunity banal for entitled men in 1944, he tossed her out of the car,
forcing her to hike home. When they met again at the house (she’d been living
with her employer’s family), he hauled off and smacked her like he was
well-practiced in hitting women in the face. On top of this abuse, he got his
mother to accuse Diana of a theft. Seeing herself in a vulnerable position, she
hoofed it over to the office of Perry Mason. The case is brutal enough to
bother Perry and Della, but at the same time easily handled with Perry’s deft
questioning that shows the stepson to be a lying little turd. Everything is
quickly resolved – the alleged theft can be explained, Diana Regis receives handsome
compensation. And when - seemingly – the door can be shut on a nasty incident,
the plot gets thicker and thicker.
Diana's roommate, Mildred Danville, dies. There is no
doubt it was a murder. Mildred was found, shot, in soil soaked with rain.
Evidence seems to indicate that Diana pulled the trigger. But the puzzles come
one on top of another. Why did Helen Bartsler (a war widow who apparently was close
to the victim) not tell the whole truth to Perry? Where is Mildred's diary,
which could explain a lot? And finally - was the tap on the rainwater cistern open
or closed?
This is a good detective story. The twists are intricate,
the action doesn’t let you to break away for dinner, and the dueling between
the upholders of the criminal justice system and Perry, Della and PI Paul Drake
Street is played for high stakes. They will stand behind the client, come what
may. Perry Mason - as in every book in the series - cajoles the police into acting
against their inclinations. In this one he goes around them astonishingly,
acquiring physical evidence in an audacious way. He also has to explode his own
client's lies and finally protect her from conviction.
The story is extremely dramatic - much more than in other
novels of this series – perhaps because of the effect WWII was having on the
public morale by 1944. The lingering fallout of the Pearl Harbor attack is
still being felt with the Bartsler family gravely affected by the loss of an
only son. Loss and grieving bring out not only the better angels of human
nature, but the crooks and scam artists and other lookers out for number one.
Material life has been affected too. Paul Drake doesn’t want Perry to drive his
car because Mason’s speeding and sharp turns will cause too much wear and tear
on his tires, which are hard to replace due to rubber shortages. Rainwater is caught
in cisterns so it can be used as a source of soft water for doing laundry and
washing one’s hair.
Anyway, long-time readers of this blog will know I read
too much Gardner, but this one really is exceptional.