Thursday, November 19, 2026

Perry Mason 184: TCOT Baited Hook

Note: The Perry Mason novels of the late Thirties and early Forties rock like Sister Rosetta. Highly unusual in a Mason novel to include a Biblical reference, but mindful Stoic Mason alludes to the aphorism ‘Sufficient unto the day is the evil thereof’ which appears in the Sermon on the Mount. Do not trouble yourself with what is past; it is beyond your power. Do not borrow fear from what is yet to come; it is not yours. What is yours is the present moment - this instant alone. Here and now act with reason, in community with other human beings.

Perryism to Live by: “Whoever got anything in life by being careful? Every time you stop to figure what the other fellow’s going to do, you unconsciously figure what you’d do in his place. The result is that you’re not fighting him, but yourself. You always come to a stalemate. Every time you think of a move, you think of a perfect defense. The best fighters don’t worry about what the other man may do. And if they keep things moving fast enough, the other man is too busy to do much thinking.”

The Case of the Baited Hook – Erle Stanley Gardner

The curtain rises on a midnight scene: Perry Mason’s office, dimly lit, tense with expectation. A wealthy architect enters, escorting a woman whose face is hidden behind a mask - a theatrical gesture that feels less like melodrama than desperation. He warns Mason to watch the newspapers; soon, both he and this silent figure may stand exposed to ruin. He forbids questions, forbids her speech. Mason, intrigued, accepts half of a ten-thousand-dollar bill as retainer - for the early Forties a mind-boggling amount of money and not shabby in 2027 – about $230K.

From this enigmatic opening, Gardner spins a web of intrigue that is less about blood and bullets than about ideas - law, finance, identity. A parallel thread introduces Mrs. Tump, a middle-aged advocate for a young woman whose life was shaped by an illegal adoption. Mrs. Tump is one of Gardner’s recurring tributes to forthright, intelligent womanhood -practical, shrewd, and unafraid to grapple with men and money.

The novel’s action is largely conversational: Mason in offices, fencing with evasive men whose words conceal more than they reveal. Yet Gardner makes dialogue electric. Here, talk is combat; every phrase a thrust, every pause a parry. And beneath the verbal fireworks lies substance: a complex stock swindle, a trust fund in peril, and a lucid exposition of the law of agency. Gardner challenges his readers to think, to follow the fine print of legality as closely as Mason does. This is not a book for the easily bored; it belongs among the most intricate Mason plots.

Layered into this legal labyrinth are Russian émigrés fleeing Bolshevism, an orphanage that doubles as a baby farm, and a share deal that smells of fraud. Mason’s usual task - finding the killer to clear his client - takes an ironic twist: first, he must discover who his client is. Identity itself becomes the mystery.

As always, Mason moves against the entrenched forces of police and prosecution -Holcomb, honest but rigid, brutal and dumb; Hamilton Burger, the hot-headed adversary. Gardner, with candor based on experience, indicts a system that prizes confession over truth, where disingenuous persuasion and trickery are legalized tools of the trade. Even when the police are fair according to their lights, the game is weighted in their favor.

Unlike most Mason tales, this one offers no climactic courtroom duel. Instead, we have a disciplinary hearing and a series of legal maneuvers hinging on arcane points of law - points Mason wields like rapiers, baffling his foes while Gardner renders them clear to the reader. And in the thick of it all stands Della Street, not merely a secretary but a partner in peril and strategy - a presence we happy few relish.

The Case of the Baited Hook is Gardner at his most cerebral: a drama of masks and motives, played out in words rather than fisticuffs. It is intricate, audacious, and  - like that half bill  - unfinished until the final page completes the design.

 

Monday, November 16, 2026

Perry Mason 183: Respectable People

Note:  For Erle Stanley Gardner and Georges Simenon the working- and middle-class wants order, continuity, dignity. It wants life to proceed without disruption. But anxieties - fear of loss, fear of being seen as a fraud, fear of economic vulnerability - can drive people into bad faith – i.e. increasingly elaborate evasions of authenticity and responsibility. Murder is what happens when those evasions fail. Gardner’s genius lies in seeing that the most dangerous place in American life is not the dive bar, but the well‑appointed great room where everyone insists they are decent and have far too much to lose for that to be questioned.

Respectable People Doing Improper Things

In the Perry Mason novels sometimes Gardner’s true subject is middle‑class transgression. A wealthy widow faces accusations of poisoning her first husband while hostile relatives scheme to block her forthcoming marriage (TCOT Careless Cupid). A ne’er-do-well brother, suspected of skimming ten thousand dollars from his employer, is blackmailed (TCOT Fabulous Fake). An investment counselor, trying to protect his ladylove, mishandles client funds and sparks a proxy fight, scandal and murder (TCOT Troubled Trustee). 

No uneasy member of the middle-class wants to be criminal. They want life to go smoothly. But things get out of hand in traditional noir fashion. Take TCOT Howling Dog, where a perfectly ordinary woman Thelma finds herself entangled with Clinton. Thelma found Clinton “very attractive,” mistaking his handsome looks for the promise of lasting devotion. For him, she killed two people. Though he helped bury the bodies, he rejected her, fearing she would someday kill him to silence what he knew. He was right since Thelma killed Clinton too.  Gardner understands that the middle class does not crave chaos; it craves stability and continuity. Heinous acts are committed for preservation of status, of freedom, of reputation.

Again and again Mason’s interviewees insist they are “not that sort of person,” by which they mean criminal, immoral, or common. Gardner delights in the distinction. Persons of interest are not that sort of person - but they are precisely the sort who will live a double life (TCOT Bigamous Spouse), make date rape a hobby (TCOT Waylaid Wolf), commission the creation of fake Gauguins (TCOT Reluctant Model), extricate themselves from a hit-and-run scandal by pinning it on a double (TCOT Mischievous Doll) or scheme to declare an elderly relative incompetent and seize his assets (TCOT Beautiful Beggar). The machinery of greed and malice hums along politely, powered by people who would be appalled by vulgar wrongdoing but quite content with discreet theft, blackmail and worse.

This is why Gardner’s world feels so different from hardboiled fiction. The danger is not in seedy hotel rooms or slum alleys or corrupt mining towns; it is in the walk-in closet. Violence erupts not from animal impulse but from the fear of loss of status (TCOT Queenly Contestant) or the fear of looking poor (TCOT Worried Waitress). Mason’s savvy lies in recognizing that crime is a consequence of existing conditions, often intolerable. The same internal pressures that make one a “solid citizen” - fear of missing a money-making opportunity, fear of not having the right connections - can, under external pressure, make one an accessory or a culprit.

Perry Mason does not roll his eyes at the antics of the middle-class. He knows most of their chiseling practices come from their trying to cope with economic conventions and social expectations. He understands the fear of exposure and embarrassment, the terror of seeming an imposter, the way maintaining a clean record can become a motive.

Friday, November 13, 2026

The Ides of The Thirties: Streamline Express

Note: Evelyn Venable radiated luminous intelligence and poise, blending wit, warmth, and quiet daring. Her performances shimmered with modern grace, subtle humor, and emotional clarity, leaving an enduring impression of elegance, curiosity, and individuality. And 1930s Hollywood didn't have the foggiest notion what to do with her. She had a short acting career, but became a Latinist at UCLA.

Streamline Express
1935 / 1:11
Tagline: “Drama on the Rails, Comedy off the Rails!”
[internet archive]

This period dramedy opens with a burst of optimistic Thirties music similar to Ted Lewis-style jazz promising There’s a New Day Coming. But what follows is more of a nostalgic curiosity than a rediscovered gem. It’s a B-picture with Broadway dreams, a streamlined train, and a plot that chugs along with more style than substance.

Evelyn Venable stars as Patricia Wallace, a Broadway diva with a spine of steel and a fiancé of mush (Ralph Forbes). Tired of being berated in front of the company by her director (Victor Jory, all smarm and swagger), she bolts from the stage and onto the latest marvel of modernity: a coast-to-coast train that promises California in 20 hours. It’s Grand Hotel on rails, with a cross-section of American types packed into sleek compartments and art deco corridors.

The film’s premise is promising, and the first act delivers some snappy, rough-edged dialogue that captures the pre-Code bite. But the story quickly derails into a mix of romantic manipulation and half-hearted satire. Jory’s director, in a move that would raise eyebrows even in 1934, bribes his way into a steward’s uniform to stalk - er, win back - his leading lady. His antics are meant to be bold and charming to win the lady fair; today, they read more like a case study in gaslighting and sexual harassment with hints of retaliation.

Venable, always a luminous presence, gets her moment – literally - at the 51-minute mark when she lets her hair down, figuratively and literally. It’s not quite as breath-taking as her scene on the staircase in Death Takes a Holiday, but it’s a reminder of her quiet screen magnetism. Her transformation from distressed damsel to righteous fury is the film’s most satisfying arc, even if it’s wrapped in a bow of romantic reconciliation after Jory takes a shoe to her sit-down. "Well sir, the past?” chimes in Theodor “Clem” Adorno. “That’s a whole 'nother country... I reckon they do things a mite different over yonder. Kinda like visitin’ Aunt Tilly’s - nothin’ makes a lick o’ sense, but you smile polite anyhow.”

The supporting cast does what it can. Esther Ralston is elegant but underused, and Erin O’Brien-Moore brings a touch of dignity to a subplot that barely registers. The dialogue veers into the risqué with lines that would make a Hays Code censor twitch. A chorine says, “If he yelled at me like that, I’d call out the Marines,” to which a smart-aleck replies “Yeah, you could call them all out by name.”

Visually, it’s all clean lines and austere columns - Thirties modernism on the cheap. The confined setting gives it a stagey feel, which might have worked better if the script had more pizzazz or the characters more depth.

In the end, this is a film for the completists, for movie-goers who pat themselves on the back because they know their Evelyn Venable from their Rochelle Hudson, who appreciate a train movie, good or not. It’s not even close to essential viewing, but it’s a pleasant enough ride for a snowy Saturday night, especially if you’re in the mood for a little vintage escapism.

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Perry Mason 182: TCOT Daring Decoy

Note: In this 1957 mystery, an elevator operator is nose-deep in a twenty-five-cent novel titled No Smog Tomorrow. Which tells you two things - first, Los Angeles was already choking on smog in the Eisenhower era, and second, you could buy an entire novel for less than the price of a cup of coffee today. Twenty-five cents! You can’t even get a parking meter to smile for that. Meanwhile, Mason has upgraded his fuel. No more bourbon or rye - he’s drinking Scotch with soda now. Was rye seen as a Depression-era drink, or was scotch just a sign that even Perry needs something rich and peaty to wash down the taste of other people’s troubles?

The Case of the Daring Decoy – Erle Stanley Gardner

Jerry Conway was thirty-five, handsome in a way that made secretaries blush and competitors sharpen their knives. He had oil under his fingernails and ambition in his bloodstream. What he didn’t have was time. Gifford Farrell, ex-employee turned Judas, was mounting a proxy fight to pry Conway’s company from his grip. Farrell had the moustache for villainy and the charm to make it stick.

Then came The Woman. There’s always a woman, isn’t there? She telephoned with promises of salvation wrapped in secrecy. If Jerry wanted her information, he’d have to play her game - switch cabs, dodge shadows, and meet her in a hotel that smelled of old wallpaper and older sins. He opened the door expecting answers and found a different woman, wearing nothing but underwear, a mudpack, and a revolver. Hubba, as they used to say. Hubba.

The gun coughed once before Jerry wrestled it away. He left with the weapon and a sense that the floor beneath him had tilted. Later, Perry Mason and Paul Drake walked into the same room and found another woman - beautiful, lifeless, and punctuated by a bullet from Jerry’s gun. The frame was perfect, like a picture in a gilt frame, except for the blood.

From there, the story spirals. Two women, one dead, one vanished. Two guns - or is it one?

A room-service tray with peas that matter more than they should. A mudpack that hides more than pores. Mason moves through it all with his usual calm, though even he cracks a joke or two. There’s comedy here, brittle and bright, and a flicker of romance that feels like a match struck in a dark room.

Hamilton Burger circles like a shark that smells blood and ethics. He wants Jerry for murder and Mason for accessory. Mason, gallant as ever, saves his sharpest thrust for a courtroom scene where he springs a trap so elegant it could hang in a museum. Della Street appears briefly, but when she does, it’s a humdinger - a moment that reminds you why Perry fights so hard.

In the end, the plot runs as smooth as a just-tuned engine. You might even guess the killer if you’re alert, though Gardner would smile at your confidence. Because in this world, motives are murky, masks slip, and the truth - when it comes - is just another stranger in a hotel room.

 

 

Monday, November 9, 2026

Matinee Musings: Ruth Chatterton’s Beauty

Note: I’m old so I take it for granted that beauty, physical characteristics, and charisma are legitimate objects of analysis. Film is a visual medium. Faces, bodies, and presence are part of meaning as well as the reason actors and actresses got hired. I note that some modern bloggers – i.e. whose parents were still wearing three-cornered pants when I was content watching* Casablanca and My Favorite Wife as a teenager - often avoid that territory entirely because, I suspect, they associate talking about looks with objectification. 

She Doesn’t Pose - She Decides: My Late Appreciation of Ruth Chatterton

When I was younger - young enough to think youth itself a credential - I used to admire Ann Sheridan and Ida Lupino for their looks. That was the word for it then: looks. It covered a lot of ground and excused a good deal of laziness. You saw a face, you approved of it, and that was that.

Time passes, and if you are lucky it takes some of your certainties with it. You begin to notice other things. In my case, it was Ruth Chatterton.

Chatterton came to pictures late, which is another way of saying she came prepared. In her late thirties, she had none of the damp innocence - think Evelyn Venable or Rochelle Hudson - the studios liked to photograph and sell. Chatterton looked as though she knew what she was doing and, worse for the illusion of romance, why she was doing it. In The Rich are Always with Us or Charming Sinners she doesn’t ask for your belief; she proceeds as if she already has it. The remarkable thing is that she usually does.

There are actresses who feel (naturalistic Myrna Loy), and actresses who show that they feel (passionate Bette Davis). Chatterton gives the impression of thinking. You can watch something occur to her. It is not a trick and it is not decoration. It is an activity. Her face does not simply register emotion; it arrives at it. That is where her beauty begins to assert itself, makes her character complicated and fascinating. The movie-goer is not looking at a set of features but at a process of blending thinking and feeling.

She’d been on the stage since she was a girl, and the stage is a hard teacher. It does not forgive vagueness. By the time she reached the camera she knew how to use her face the way a good speaker uses grammar. Early sound pictures needed that. The microphone was merciless. Stage-trained Chatterton could deliver a line properly.

If you line her up with her contemporaries, the differences are plain enough. Janet Gaynor had that breakable quality, as if a strong opinion might do her damage. Miriam Hopkins fluttered; she seemed to be in a state of continual adjustment. Dolores del Río belonged to another climate altogether – the border ethereal maybe. Chatterton, by contrast, looks as though she has already made up her mind. The jaw is set, the gaze direct. She does not invite; she considers and concludes. It suited the Pre-Code moment, when a woman might be allowed to know something and act on it as though she were her own person, though the movie-goer yelled at her, begged her, to do something else, like not marry the worthless Jim in Sarah and Son. Yet she could turn, when required, and show hurt in a way that suggested not weakness but cost, as in Anybody's Woman and The Laughing Lady. There were men in the audience who wanted to comfort her, and others who suspected she would not thank them for it.

There is also the matter of stillness. Genuine poise is so rare as to be unexpected, but it’s a real strength. Chatterton can stand in a scene and let it come to her. She does not arrange herself for the camera; she occupies the space and obliges the camera to adjust. The effect is not dramatic in the usual sense. The tranquility is closer to authority, to presence, to excellence. Like the pause between two notes, it gives shape to what surrounds it.

All this is to say that her beauty does not begin or end with her features, which are good enough without being extraordinary. It lies in a combination of intelligence, control, and a certain independence of manner that refuses to apologize for itself. You are aware of a mind at work and of a will behind it. There were men in the audience who wanted to get her opinion on something (or anything), and others who suspected she would not tell them what they wanted to hear. 

I used to think beauty was something you could recognize at once and be done with. Chatterton suggests otherwise. She is beautiful in the way a well-made argument is convincing: you follow it, you wonder at it, you resist it even, and in the end you find you have been persuaded.

++++++++++

* On TV in Detroit from 1956 to 1983, Bill Kennedy hosted old movies weekdays with a dry, sardonic wit, for example, dismissing Ida Lupino’s epic courtroom meltdown in They Drive by Night as “pretty corny.” On a simple studio set, he introduced movies, ran contests and giveaways, chatted with viewers, and interviewed visiting stars - becoming a familiar, slightly irascible afternoon companion for local audiences.

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Perry Mason 181: Ride the High Iron

Note: Raymond Burr loved to act, appearing in dozens of feature films between 1946 and 1957, of which many built him up as an icon of film noir. He typecast as the villain because his stoutness gave him a commanding menacing presence. Film historian Alain Silver concluded that Burr's most significant work in the genre is in ten films: Desperate (1947), Sleep, My Love (1948), Raw Deal (1948), Pitfall (1948), Abandoned (1949), Red Light (1949), M (1951), His Kind of Woman (1951), and The Blue Gardenia (1953).

Ride the High Iron
1956 / 1:09
Tagline: “Sure I'll Keep Your Name Out of the Papers, Baby...For a Price..”
[internet archive]

Raymond Burr dominates this low-budget melodrama with a performance that underscores controlled menace. His character’s worldview - dog-eat-dog, shaped by immigrant roots and a sense of perpetual scarcity - gives the film its sharpest edge. Burr embodies a man who believes success is fragile and must be seized with both fists, and that conviction radiates through every scene.

The movie’s real fascination lies in its blunt commentary on class and identity. It probes the uneasy tension between aspiration and authenticity, showing how the hunger to escape one’s origins can hollow out a sense of self. The contrast between Burr’s aggressive self-fashioning and the quiet dignity of working-class values becomes a cultural critique as much as a character study.

Though made for television, the film ambitiously tackles themes of social mobility, pride, and the corrosive effects of shame. Sally Forrest evokes Ida Lupino’s emotional intensity, and while Don Taylor never quite matches Burr’s ferocity, the trio’s dynamic underscores the film’s central question: what does it cost to reinvent yourself - and is the price ever worth paying?

Thursday, November 5, 2026

The Nones of The Thirties: Hitch Hike Lady

Note: In City Limits (1934) two homeless guys teach a tycoon to enjoy life. In Among the Missing (1934) a little old lady turns a front into a home. In The Fall Guy (1930) a sorely-tried woman supports both her teenager of a husband and her impossible brother with a loyalty that borders on sainthood. Midnight Mary (1933) is a fast, economical crime melodrama with a tough shell but a tender center – the heroine’s longing for a better life and real connection gives the film its emotional weight. This is another little movie of the time, with a big soul.

Hitch Hike Lady
1935 / 1:16
Tagline: “Highway hilarity that will tie up titter traffic!”
[internet archive]

This modest Depression-era comedy-drama offers more than its Poverty Row pedigree might suggest. It’s a tale of unexpected friendship and the quiet dignity of an older woman determined to find her son - and peace of mind - on the other side of the world.

Alison Skipworth, in a performance that is both sturdy and touching, plays Mrs. Amelia Blake, a British mother who believes her son is thriving as an orange farmer in California. In truth, he’s serving time in San Quentin, but the film wisely delays that revelation, allowing us to see Mrs. Blake not as a victim of deception, but as a woman of hope and grit.

The story unfolds with a series of misadventures that feel both comic and poignant. Mrs. Blake’s journey from Kent to California is marked by hardship and humanity. Her bond with Judy (Mae Clarke), a young woman adrift in the economic whirlpools of the 1930s, is the emotional core of the film. Their shared struggles - hunger, exhaustion, and the indignities of hitchhiking - forge a friendship that feels sincere.

James Ellison provides romantic interest as Jimmy, a trailer salesman with a heart, and Arthur Treacher and Warren Hymer add comic relief as con men with more affability than menace. The ensemble is surprisingly effective, and the film’s tone - while occasionally veering into melodrama - remains grounded in character.

Mrs. Blake: My son has an orange ranch in California. I wonder if you've heard of it.
Mortimer: Really? What does your son call his estate?
Mrs. Blake: Rancho San Quentin. I see you have heard of it.
Cluck: Heard of it? Why lady...
Mortimer (poking Cluck to shut up): Of course we've heard of it. It's one of the most arresting places in America. Not only is the fruit of California golden, Cluck my knave, but so is silence.
Mrs. Blake: Oh, let him tell me about it.
Mortimer: No, no. He's not very poetic. I don't think he'd do it justice.
Cluck: Aw, you see, when it comes to talkin', I'm almost a dummy. 
Mortimer (as only an Englishman could say it): Yeah.

In one episode, the trailer unhitches from its coupling and ends up in the camp of large band of harvesters. The itinerant field workers immediately want to help Mrs. Blake and the two rogues by feeding them and making sure they aren’t hurt. The kindness of the salt of the earth was a strong theme in the Thirties; perhaps we Americans wanted to reassure ourselves that WWI, the rowdy Twenties, and the Depression didn’t turn us into complete monsters that had forgotten basic rules like “help others in trouble.”

The episode ends up with Mrs. Blake preventing vigilante justice from tar and feathering the two rascals for which they feel grateful enough to decide they owe her something. It’s weird but the juxtaposition of the frightening reality of mob violence and the cultural values of communal support and reciprocity seems quintessentially American.

Alison Skipworth was often cast as a battleaxe or harridan but here she is a nice old lady with a big soul. Arthur Treacher is an amusing blowhard with a pompous vocabulary and makes a hilarious contrast with inarticulate Warren Hymer who plays the lug-thug-mug in such a way that the movie-goer does not get short of breath (I’m looking at you, Leo Gorcey). James Ellison and Mae Clarke make an attractive couple. Like I always say, Mae Clarke deserves a lot better than to be remembered only for that nasty grapefruit scene. In this she is a spark of life, smart, sassy, delightful, resilient.

Yes, the plot is thin and the pacing uneven, but the film’s feeling is in the right place. It’s a story about finding connection in unlikely places, and about the strength of women who refuse to be defined by their circumstances. For viewers willing to look past its modest production values, this is a warm movie with a surprising amount of soul.