The Case of the
Green-eyed Sister – Erle Stanley Gardner
What has poor old Ned Bain done to deserve such a
troubled old age? He’s got the guilts on account of over-dutiful daughter
Hattie who’s sacrificed her chance at a loving husband and family so she could
nurse him and his dodgy heart. Instead of getting an honest job like any man
should, his son Jarret has married rich and spends his wife’s money looking at
ruins – i.e. fallen down buildings -- in
the Yucatan. His daughter Sylvia is a loose-cannon manipulator and divorcee to
boot. Snooty and cold Sylvia makes a poor impression on intuitive Della Street
who says of Sylvia, "She'd cut your heart out for thirty-seven
cents."
As if his children were not worry enough, a rum friend,
J.J. Fritch from the past is trying to blackmail him. J.J. is threatening to
tell the bank that Ned’s fortune is based on money stolen in a heist, which
would wipe out the Bain family. J.J. is using crooked PI Brogan to plague him.
Daughter Sylvia goes to Perry Mason
The action careens around tight corners with the upshot
being Perry Mason finds himself having to defend daughter Hattie on a murder
charge. Who would have thought such a mousey woman would take a bad guy out
with an icepick?
Gardner has fun – and certain readers will too – as Mason
dissects improper police procedure such as witness priming and sloppy police
procedure such as not bothering to look for evidence. This happens so often in
Perry Mason novels that they could be considered anti-police procedurals. The
trial scene in Chapter Fourteen, about 50 pages, is one of the longest in all
the Gardner novels.
The reveal is quite clever and counts as one of the more famous endings among Mason fans. Mystery fans who like retro 1950s fashion and word play (“lead pipe cinch”) will enjoy this readable book.
.
The reveal is quite clever and counts as one of the more famous endings among Mason fans. Mystery fans who like retro 1950s fashion and word play (“lead pipe cinch”) will enjoy this readable book.
.
No comments:
Post a Comment