Friday, August 24, 2018

A Man Could Stand Up: A Classic that Scares You

I read this book for the Back to the Classics Challenge 2018.

Lots of us post-moderns connect with modernist writers because we share their mistrust of power in the hands of the fallible agents of government and religion and reject many traditional beliefs. But one baddish thing to do to anybody is take away their hope for a better future. The classic tetralogy Parade’s End scares me because modernist writers, especially those coming out of World War I like Ford, were so cynical and disillusioned that the reader’s hope gets cuffed around. I thought that re-reading the novels one after another (not the way I read them about 3 or 4 years ago) would steel me, get me beyond feeling mere anger and frustration with the same old gaga fools getting the younger generation into the suck for the same stupid reasons. Emotional outcome: mixed.

A Man Could Stand Up – Ford Madox Ford

This is the third volume in the tetralogy. After years of separation and uncertainty for the duration of hostilities, the army veteran Christopher Tietjens and his beloved Valentine Wannop see each other again on the day of the armistice. But tormented by images of the horrible war and the prolonged stress of combat, Tietjens is in a bad way with PTSD. He suffers from anxiety and obsessive guilt that he was responsible for a terrible wound sustained by his subaltern. Tietjens’ harpy of a wife Sylvia has sold all his furniture and he returns from the war to an empty house.

However, now that the war has ended, with the old world of Victorianism and feudal traditions tossed in the trash heap by independent-minded people, Tietjens has the desperate strength to escape the relentless malice and cruelty of his hateful wife and is ready to confess his love for Valentine. So far he had refused to do this for the conventional reason that a gentleman doesn’t divorce his wife. The theme Ford examines is that after the First World War, nothing is going to be same. Men will return from the war in pain:

Hitherto, [Valentine] had thought of the War as physical suffering only: now she saw it only as mental torture. Immense miles and miles of anguish in darkened minds. That remained. Men might stand up on hill, but the mental torture could not be expelled.

From the nightmare of war and the chaos of a disoriented present, the lovers have the chance of a new beginning in a cottage with Tietjens selling old furniture to rich snooty Americans eager to snap up bargains. Tietjens and Valentine’s  goal is to lead a life together, where they no longer have to duck social censure, and to do what they respect each other for: to stand up a.k.a. be wise, brave, fair, and disciplined to do work that they think is important.

The cruelty of Sylvia and all power holders breaks the heart of the reader. Ford's ability to recognize and describe the effects of historical events on the souls of sensitive wise people makes him a great writer. It’s a good novel, if the reader is tough enough to manage heartbreak and roiling blood pressure and attentive enough to follow involved modernist "impressionistic realism."

No comments:

Post a Comment