Germania –
Simon Winder
The German-American ethnicity disappeared during the war frenzy that accompanied
US entry into World War I. We in the born-in-the-Fifties generation know the
Germans as victims, bystanders or perps during the Hitler time. And there our
knowledge stops. According to English writer Simon Winder, the British are not
much more familiar with that serious presence in Middle Europe.
Winder developed his interest in the Germans and their
country when he was only a child. Since then he has read widely in German
history and travelled extensively to out of the way spots that have preserved
pre-1914 Germany. This wonderful book is approximately 75% popular history and
25% travelogue. In chronological order, he covers the German-speaking peoples
from the Holy Roman Empire to 1933 (after which he feels his “facetious
anecdotes” are inappropriate). Winder discusses, among many other topics, food,
castles, landscapes, writers, and mad local aristocrats. His writing is
accessible and often quite funny.
However wonderful Winder’s British way with words, the
only drawbacks also relate to language. He overuses adjectives, especially
“disgusting,” “dopey,” and “delusive.” An editor should’ve checked his
excessive use of “It’s impossible not to imagine…” and “It’s hard not to imagine
….” An attentive proofreader should’ve saved him from “interned” for “interred”
and the embarrassing “bale” in “bail out,” and “overweaning” for “overweening.”
Still, any reader curious about Germany’s overall history but not up to more serious historical writing would have an entertaining and informative time with this book.
Maybe they will fix the mistakes in a second edition?
ReplyDeleteI read the author's "The Man Who Saved Britain" a few years ago which was supposed to be about James Bond...and it was. But the subtitle was "A Personal Journey into the Disturbing World of James Bond" and I found the book had too much of Winder's personal journey and not enough of Bond/Ian Fleming.
I am interested in German history but I wonder if this book will also have more personal details than I want.
I think the author was successful in balancing history and his opinionated, funny and mean (in that uniquely English way) reminiscences of his trips to Germany and Austria. He covers German eccentrics pretty hilariously - the English appreciate a good eccentric.
ReplyDelete