Note: This week is Stoic Week 2026, the yearly invitation to
test whether your troubles shrink when viewed from the perspective of eternity.
It’s free, online, and costs substantially less than angrily refreshing the
news every fifteen minutes. Since I no longer have students upon whom to
inflict learning points, I need somewhere to redirect what D. H. Lawrence
called “the passion of instruction” before campus security finds me conducting
impromptu seminars on collective nouns.
The Stoics were Socratics so they urged “Moderation in all things.” Managing our unhelpful thoughts and feelings is crucial if we want to experience serenity and deal with the inevitable sufferings of life. This is also crucial because our unhelpful cognitive silliness and craziness will literally break our hearts.
The Influence of the Mind on the Body (1908)
Paul Dubois The Influence of the Mind on the Body is one of the earliest and most influential attempts to explain how thoughts, emotions, and beliefs affect physical health. Writing as a Swiss neurologist and psychiatrist in 1908, Dubois challenged the prevailing medical view that mind and body operated as separate realms. His central argument was simple but far-reaching: many physical symptoms are shaped, intensified, or sustained by patterns of thought, particularly fear, anxiety, and suggestion.
Viewed today, the book reads almost like a bridge between medicine and Stoicism.
Dubois observed that patients frequently worsen their suffering by dwelling on symptoms or interpreting ordinary bodily sensations as signs of catastrophe. Fear creates vigilance, vigilance creates anxiety, and anxiety amplifies physical discomfort. He argued that both external suggestion, from physicians, family, and society, and internal suggestion, from one's own worries and expectations, can have profound effects on health. As a result, treatment should address not only disease but also the patient's beliefs about disease.
His preferred method, sometimes called "moral therapy," relied less on drugs than on conversation, education, and the correction of harmful thought patterns. The physician's task was to help patients replace fear with understanding and uncertainty with rational judgment. In essence, Dubois sought to teach patients how to govern their own minds.
Modern science has largely vindicated his intuition. While Dubois lacked the language of modern neuroscience, endocrinology, and immunology, contemporary research confirms that mental and physical processes are deeply interconnected. Chronic stress activates the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, elevating cortisol levels and contributing to inflammation, cardiovascular disease, digestive disorders, and metabolic dysfunction. What Dubois called worry and anxiety are now understood as physiological events that affect the entire body.
His insights regarding expectation have also been remarkably durable. The placebo effect demonstrates that belief can produce measurable changes in pain perception, brain chemistry, and physical functioning. Neuroimaging studies reveal that expectations alter activity in specific brain networks, lending scientific support to Dubois's claim that suggestion can create genuine bodily effects.
Perhaps the modern discipline most closely aligned with Dubois is cognitive behavioral therapy. Like CBT, his approach focused on identifying distorted beliefs, challenging unhelpful assumptions, and cultivating more balanced interpretations of experience. Although less systematic than contemporary psychotherapy, Dubois anticipated many of its central principles decades before the field formally emerged.
The connection to Stoicism is equally striking. Epictetus taught that people are disturbed not by events themselves but by their judgments about those events. Dubois repeatedly arrives at a similar conclusion. Patients often suffer not only from symptoms but from the fear, interpretations, and expectations attached to those symptoms. In both systems, the path toward relief begins with examining one's judgments.
Stoicism and Dubois share the conviction that tranquility depends upon distinguishing between what is and what we imagine. Both emphasize rational self-examination, disciplined attention to thought, and resistance to catastrophic thinking. A Stoic confronting illness seeks to judge symptoms accurately rather than emotionally. Dubois encouraged precisely the same habit. His efforts to teach patients calm interpretation, rather than fearful speculation, closely resemble Stoic exercises in cognitive reframing.
Not surprisingly, Dubois even prescribed reading Seneca* to some patients. He recognized that Stoic philosophy offered practical tools for reducing anxiety and restoring perspective. Practices such as monitoring internal dialogue, accepting uncertainty, and focusing on what lies within one's control complement his therapeutic methods almost perfectly.
There are differences. The Stoics pursued virtue and inner freedom as the highest goals of life, while Dubois was primarily interested in improving health and reducing suffering. Yet both arrive at a shared insight: the mind is an active participant in shaping experience and that shaping has an effect on health and well-being.
______
No comments:
Post a Comment