Note: For Erle Stanley Gardner and Georges Simenon the working- and middle-class wants order, continuity, dignity. It wants life to proceed without disruption. But anxieties - fear of loss, fear of being seen as a fraud, fear of economic vulnerability - can drive people into bad faith – i.e. increasingly elaborate evasions of authenticity and responsibility. Murder is what happens when those evasions fail. Gardner’s genius lies in seeing that the most dangerous place in American life is not the dive bar, but the well‑appointed great room where everyone insists they are decent and have far too much to lose for that to be questioned.
Respectable People Doing Improper Things
In the Perry Mason novels murder is not a crime of passion. Murder is an outcome that forces the respectable to confront their own bad behavior. Sometimes Gardner’s true subject is middle‑class transgression. A wealthy widow faces accusations of poisoning her first husband while hostile relatives scheme to block her forthcoming marriage (TCOT Careless Cupid). A ne’er-do-well brother, suspected of skimming ten thousand dollars from his employer, is blackmailed (TCOT Fabulous Fake). An investment counselor, trying to protect his ladylove, mishandles client funds and sparks a proxy fight, scandal and murder (TCOT Troubled Trustee). Crime, in these stories, is what happens when propriety is strained past its ability to pretend wrong-doing isn’t happening.
No uneasy member of the middle-class wants to be criminal. They want life to go smoothly. But things get out of hand in traditional noir fashion. Take TCOT Howling Dog, where a perfectly ordinary woman Thelma finds herself entangled with Clinton. Thelma found Clinton “very attractive,” mistaking his handsome looks for the promise of lasting devotion. For him, she killed two people. Though he helped bury the bodies, he rejected her, fearing she would someday kill him to silence what he knew. He was right since Thelma killed Clinton too. Gardner understands that the middle class does not crave chaos; it craves stability and continuity. Heinous acts are committed not for thrill but for preservation of status, of freedom, of reputation.
Again and again Mason’s interviewees insist they are “not that sort of person,” by which they mean criminal, immoral, or common. Gardner delights in the distinction. Persons of interest are not that sort of person - but they are precisely the sort who will live a double life (TCOT Bigamous Spouse), make date rape a hobby (TCOT Waylaid Wolf), commission the creation of fake Gauguins (TCOT Reluctant Model), extricate themselves from a hit-and-run scandal by pinning it on a double (TCOT Mischievous Doll) or scheme to declare an elderly relative incompetent and seize his assets (TCOT Beautiful Beggar). The machinery of greed and malice hums along politely, powered by people who would be appalled by vulgar wrongdoing but quite content with discreet theft, blackmail and worse.
This is why Gardner’s world feels so different from hardboiled fiction. The danger is not in seedy hotel rooms or slum alleys or corrupt mining towns; it is in the walk-in closet. Violence erupts not from animal impulse but from the fear of loss of status (TCOT Queenly Contestant) or the fear of looking poor (TCOT Worried Waitress). Mason’s savvy lies in recognizing that crime is a consequence of existing conditions, often intolerable. The same internal pressures that make one a “solid citizen” - fear of missing a money-making opportunity, fear of not having the right connections - can, under external pressure, make one an accessory or a culprit.
Perry Mason does not roll his eyes at the antics of the middle-class. He knows most of their chiseling practices come from their trying to cope with economic conventions. He understands the fear of exposure and embarrassment, the terror of seeming an imposter, the way maintaining a clean record can become a motive.
No comments:
Post a Comment