I read this book for the Mount TBR Reading Challenge hosted over
at My
Reader’s Block from January 1 – December 31, 2017. The challenge is to read
books that you already own.
Man Disconnected:
How Technology has Sabotaged What it Means to be Male - Philip Zimbardo and
Nikita D. Coulombe
Psychologist Philip Zimbardo is most well-known for the Stanford
Prison Experiment and his work on shyness.
In this 2014 book, he and a colleague examine the perturbing state of young
males in post-modern society all over the world. Discussed here are studies
showing that boys are disenchanted with an educational system that doesn’t
teach in modes that boys prefer. Along
with reading, boys put the whole educational enterprise into the bucket
labelled “a girl thing.” Another growing tendency is for boys to be attracted
to and maintain association with exclusively male-dominated social groupings. Guys
are a lot more predictiable and thus safer; girls stand in the middle of social
minefields.
Other alarming symptoms are the tendency for boys to be
alone in their rooms too much, spending too much time with video games and
online porn. Doing so, they consume and create nothing. Living at home with
their parents, they don’t even help with chores because, as males, they feel
entitled to be waited on.
I think the best part of the initial part of the book is
the summary of research examining what happens to brain chemistry when boys
play video games and click through hundreds of online pornographic images. 13
hours a week with video games is the average for teenage boys; by the time they
are 21 the average boy has spent 10,000 hours with video games, the time it
takes to get two bachelor degrees at a university. The values of videogames are
about domination and competition, which males like.
The average for porn is two hours a week, usually consumed
as a break from gaming. Zimbardo describes “arousal addiction,” in these
terms: “in order to get the same amount
of stimulation, you need new material, seeing the same images over and over
again becomes uninteresting after a short time. The key is novelty of visual
experience.” Given the frightening endlessness of internet porn, millions of
hot babes beckon. Porn also induces ED because averagely-endowed males compare
themselves with huge-peckered porn stars and then worry about their ability to
last a half-hour like the porn dudes seem to. Basically porn is poison for the
brain.
The researchers point to many reasons for these troubling
signs. Too many families have parents that work all the time, leaving teenage
boys without their father’s advice or even physical presence. Boys talk to
father only about 30 minutes a week on the average, while spending hours in
front of screens. Millions of boys are living without fathers at all, which causes
many problems for mothers and sons (at least) when boys hit adolescence. Boys
are dealing with myths of the patriarchy (boys must be strong at all times,
boys must lead at all times) versus post-modern expectations for boys to be
caring, empathic and always taking” no” to mean “no.” Intractable unemployment
and shrinkage in the number of jobs where males can use their hands along with
their brains have not helped boys find a place is society either.
The final third of the book tells what government,
schools, men, and women can do to improve the problems that young males face in
our culture. I thought the book was worth reading as a description of the
problems. Much interesting research was cited, which was a plus. On the other
hand, various experts like George Carlin were cited and hobgoblins such as
“political correctness” were invoked as explanations. As always, keep the
critical-thinking cap on. Firmly.
Leonard Sax has written on this topic - Boys Adrift was one of his books that I've read. The role of technology is interesting & frightening. I recently finished a book called 'We' by Yegevny Zamyatin. Dystopian type of book where technology makes possible a mechanised society. Thoughtful review!
ReplyDelete