Note: A shorter review of this mystery was published for a more general audience right here. The review below is for the hard-core readers, readers that need a tutorial on topics of 1959, and ESL students.
The Case of the
Mythical Monkeys - Erle Stanley Gardner
A professional all the way down to the ground, Gardner
was conscious of keeping his long-time readers engaged with a blend of familiar
characters and new twists and digressions. In this 1959 outing, the love
interest between plucky heroine Gladys and mysterious but unwolfish John has
some sexy talk more typical in a Cool and
Lam novel than a prim Mason novel.
Also untypically, the climax does not occur in the
courtroom but in the judge’s chambers. The judge – who has the Gardnerian impressive
name of Arvis Bagby -- has many more lines than usual and this a bigger chance
to express a little personality.
Really strangely, DA Hamilton Burger does not want to
play the part of a poodle lap dog to another government entity, so much so that
the judge has to admonish the DA to be more cooperative, as a representative of
the highest ideals of justice. But driven by memories of past bitter
experience, Burger still doesn’t want to because of his animus toward Mason.
Hamilton Burger, his lips
clamped in a tight line of anger, jerked his head at Perry Mason and said, “Not
when you’re dealing with Mason – we’re not even dealing. He’s handing us out
the cards he wants us to have, some of them from the top of the deck, some of
them from the middle of the deck, some of them from the bottom of the deck, and
some of them he’s keeping up his sleeve.”
Later, Mason demonstrates more confidence in Lt. Tragg’s
ability as a detective than the DA does. Burger worries about a bad effect on
public relations due to newspaper criticism, and tells the judge he doesn’t
have the right to proceed, for which the judge lambastes him. Hey, some people
read fantasy with orks, I read fantasy about the criminal justice system.
Finally, in a curious digression Gardner expresses a
theory of factors that makes best-sellers fly off the shelf, at least in the
late 1950s. The writer in this novel, Miss Mauvis Niles Meade, has carefully
cultivated a bad girl image to become one of the hottest three-named writers on
the scene. Her lurid best-selling novel Chop
the Man Down was fueled by her cynical sizing up of the literary market and
the public taste. She confesses to Mason:
….I’m under no
illusions as to the literary quality of my book. You know, people are
essentially hypocrites. They love to lecture about morality but they love to
read about immorality.
An
attractive young woman can write the story about a heroine whose clothes keep
coming off and describe the resultant consequences in detail. People are shocked. But people love to be
shocked
If you’ll
notice the bestsellers and analyze them carefully you’ll find that most of the
sex books written by attractive women whose photographs look very seductive on
the dust jackets are the stories that sell in big figures.
Women readers
love to read about sex from the standpoint of a woman. Men like to look at the
dish pictured on the cover and wonder just how it happened that she learned
learn all those details about the things which are described in the book and
which nice girls aren’t supposed to know. It makes for speculation -- and
sales.
Gardner is clearly talking about the influence of the
1956 novel Peyton Place by Grace
Metalious. It was not only a best-seller – selling 30 million copies, it was a
cultural phenomenon. I wonder if Peyton
Place would be a good choice to read for a reading challenge. Here’re the
opening lines:
Indian summer is like a woman.
Ripe, hotly passionate, but fickle, she comes and goes as she pleases so that
one is never sure whether she will come at all, nor for how long she will stay.
I'm now going to take myself somewhere quiet and isolated. And suffer a cerebrovascular insult.
Glossary: The
pandemic killed dead my part-time job of teaching ESL so my teacherly
inclinations and ways have to come out somehow. Following is a glossary of
terms used in this novel for people under 50 and non-native speakers of
English. Both groups lack knowledge of 1959 and its idioms and its cultural
touchstones and assumptions. Glossing was for my own amusement but done in the
larger hope that old-school mysteries won’t become inaccessible simply because
their vocabulary becomes quaint, opaque, embarrassing or obsolete.
·
Something
of a wolf: Other retro words for men who mask bad sexual intentions and
behaviors towards women with smooth politeness are Casanova, Don Juan, lecher,
lothario, lounge lizard, masher, philanderer, and womanizer. Youth says wolf but also uses player or cheater.
·
Road patrol
was strict that chains were required: Snow chains, or tire chains, are
devices fitted to the tires of vehicles to provide maximum traction when
driving through snow and ice.
·
The night
was as dark as velvet: Velvet is a type of woven tufted fabric in which the
cut threads are evenly distributed, with a short dense pile, giving it a unique
soft feel
·
log cabin:
a small house made of logs, usually in a rural area or wilderness
·
I can’t
stay here tonight: In 1959, single women did not spend the night in log
cabins with men. Note she warns him if he makes any unwelcome advances, he’ll
get the surprise of his life.
·
It’s a
free country. We sometimes say this to people who tell us they are going to
do something that we think is inappropriate or crazy. We also say this to
people who tell us we can’t do something.
·
It would
be just like him. It would be typical of him. Nowadays the hip say, “That’s
so you.”
·
Sleepy
head: An informal word for someone, usually a child, who looks tired and ready to sleep
·
Working
girl: An old-fashioned expression for a young girl who has a job. Because
it may also mean “prostitute,” it’s not too safe to use in conversation
nowadays.
·
I really
wanted him to make a pass. To do or say something that clearly shows one
wants to begin a romantic or sexual relationship with someone. In Perry Mason
novels, it’s highly unusual for goody-goody heroines to be talking like this.
·
Draw my
right forefinger across my throat when you say cooperation. This gesture
means that the person is angry or that you should stop what you are doing
immediately
·
Gladys,
Mauvis, Dorothy. Gladys was a popular name in the early 20th
century. Dorothy was popular in the 1920s. Mauvis is a highly unusual name that
was never popular, but sounds very glamorous and stylish.
·
Dartley
B. Irwin, Judge Arvis Bagby, Wendell Parnell Jarvis. All of these names for
men are impressive and ornate. Gardner liked to name his male professionals
these pompous names. Dukes Lawton is
a good name for a boxer because dukes
is boxing slang for hands.
·
Swell.
An old-fashioned slang word for cool.
·
The fat’s
in the fire. This idiom is said when something has been said or done that
will cause a lot of trouble. Though it dates from the 16th century
it is still used nowadays.
·
Sex,
sophistication, mystery and melodrama. Gardner goes meta. He injects these
in this novel while making genial fun of writers who inject these elements into
would-be best-sellers.
·
Make up
out of whole cloth: Lie, tell falsehoods.
·
Big shot:
an important, successful, influential person
·
Mouthpiece:
spokesperson, representative. Still used, but I think it sounds harsh.
·
It’s the
story of a woman who got around. Get
around means have sex with many different partners
·
Razzle-dazzle:
excitement, attention
·
Dough:
money
·
A man who
makes a million doesn’t want to turn around and give $900,000 to the
government. Though this sounds unbelievable today, in 1959, in the United
States, the tax rate on such a sum would be in fact 90%.
·
Patsy:
a victim of a scam or an innocent person made to seem guilty of a crime.
·
I’ll have
to think that over: Polite way to say No.
·
Lounging
pajamas: These must be seen to be believed
·
Cover
ground: discuss a certain number of topics
·
Easy on
the eye: good-looking, attractive
·
Deadly
(traffic): boring, deadly dull.
·
My
crystal ball is no bigger than yours. Fortunetellers use crystal balls to
tell the future. The speaker means that she can’t predict the future any more
accurately than anybody else.
·
Spicy
(story, romance, talk): Slightly scandalous, risquƩ, racy, blue
·
Apple pie
order: a very organized and tidy state. This is New England expression –
housewives there had a great reputation for order and neatness.
·
The
devil! Expression of confusion, surprise, anger
·
Get hung
up in (traffic, red tape, endless discussion): be slowed down by something
·
Get the
corpse tagged: Tag means identify in this case.
·
Give a
once over: To review, inspect, or examine something in a quick or cursory
fashion.
·
A cord of
wood: One cord is generally equivalent to a stack 4 × 4 × 8 feet (128 cubic
feet/3.6 cubic meters)
·
So far so
good. (Everything is) satisfactory or developing as planned up to the
current point or moment in time. This is an often used expression
·
We don’t
have a social life, to speak of. To
speak of means worth mentioning, or having any practical significance.
·
He’s a
live wire. An energetic person.
·
Draw a
blank. To be unable to find something.
·
If he’s
32, he’s done military duty somewhere. If he is 32 in 1959, he was born in
1927, which would make him a little young for WWII when the draft swept up thousands
more young men than usual. So I wonder if Paul Drake is a better detective than
mathematician.
·
Love nest:
A place where two people meet secretly to have a romantic affair.
·
“Tonight
knowing that I’m eating on an expense account, I’m going to give my stomach the
surprise of its life. I’m going to have a jumbo shrimp cocktail, consommĆ©, a
salad with anchovies across the top, a New York cut, medium rare, Lyonnaise
potatoes, the best red wine they have in the house, a side dish of creamed
onions and some hot apple pie alamode.” Paul Drake’s dream meal features no
bread but plenty of onions.
·
Shucks:
A mild exclamation of anger, annoyance, regret, or disgust. Often preceded by
the interjections "ah" or "aw."
·
Hang it!
Another mild exclamation of anger, annoyance
·
In the
worst way: very much. “I want a new car in the worst way.” This is still
often used today.
·
Cheesecake
picture: images of attractive women wearing little or no clothing.
·
Buy on a
hand to mouth basis: The purchase by a business in the smallest feasible
quantities for immediate requirements. Nowadays we say “just in time.”
·
This is
all news to me. This is something I did not know.
·
Have an
understanding with: have an agreement with, make a compromise with
·
A whale
of: a lot of
·
Carbon
paper: thin paper coated with carbon or another pigmented substance, used
for making copies of written or typed documents. Nobody that was an office
worker back in the day misses the carbon getting on their hands, clothes, face,
lap.
·
I won’t
touch it with a ten-foot pole. I do not want to become in any way involved
in or with something or someone. A deeply American expression.
·
Make
headway: make progress
·
Be a vamp:
be a woman who uses her looks and charm to seduce and exploit men. This is a
very old-fashioned word.
·
Monkey
with: adjust in an ignorant way (monkey with computer settings); waste time
with (quit monkeying with the cat and wash the dishes!)
·
Know all
the angles: To know every way or opportunity one can use in order to reach
one's goal.
·
Daring (book):
new and original in a brave way
·
Jumpy:
nervous, jittery
·
Cauliflower
ear: An ear permanently swollen and deformed by repeated blows.
·
Sounding
board: A person or group whose reactions to an idea, opinion, or point of
view serve as a measure of its effectiveness or acceptability.
·
Get a
line on: To have or obtain helpful information about somebody or something
·
Sob
sister: A writer or journalist – often female - who focuses on or
specializes in overly emotional, dramatic, or sentimental articles. This American
expression from the 1920s is not used much anymore, since nearly nobody reads
newspapers.
·
Hit
paydirt: to discover something especially after long hours of research
·
Sit tight:
To wait patiently without taking any immediate action.
·
Play dumb:
To act ignorant or uninformed (about something). At work people often play dumb
to get help
·
Be as
snug as a bug in a rug: To be warm and cozy, typically while wrapped in
blankets.
·
Hang
crepe: Be pessimistic about an outcome. Nobody uses this expression
anymore, because the custom has died out. Crepe is a lightweight fabric. A century or so ago, people used to hang
black crepe above their front door as a sign of mourning when a family member died. The custom has almost completely died out in
the United States, but fire houses hang black crepe above the doors when a
company member dies.
·
Rental
$100 a month (in 1960 dollars): This is about $900 in 2021 money, not a small
amount of dough in 1960 or 2021.
·
My word
is good. I am trustworthy, reliable.
·
Throwing
money to the birds. Wasting money
·
Personalities:
An offensive or disapproving personal remark. Still used in formal settings
like meetings, this idiom is almost always used in the negative or a negative
sense: Let’s refrain from personalities. Let’s not engage in personalities.
·
Car hop:
A server – usually female – in a drive-in restaurant.
·
Lush:
A person who is habitually drunk, a heavy drinker
·
Decorate
the mahogany: When someone buys a round
a pub or bar, they decorate the mahogany; putting cash on the bar. I doubt if
anybody uses this expression anymore, though, heaven knows, never say never.
·
Roll with
the punch: adapt yourself to unfortunate circumstances
·
Clutch at
straws: To make a desperate attempt to repair a bad situation.
·
“The
judge’s eyes twinkled.” “His face a perfectly expressionless mask.” “His eyes
narrowing.” These expressions of Gardner are his favorites and can be found
in almost all of his books
·
Smith
Corona: This company made typewriters and their supplies from 1886 to 2013.
Now they make thermal labels for barcodes. It is very unusual for Gardner to
mention brand names, even of cars. Perhaps it was against the rules of
magazines who first printed the novels as serials.
·
What’s
your line? Old-fashioned expression for What do you do?
·
Bring out
your big guns: Use your most talented players or employees
·
Tip your
hand. To reveal one's intentions, plans, secrets, or resources. This is
from the card game poker if you let someone else see the cards you’re currently
holding (one's "hand").
·
I’m in
his hands. Under his control or influence.
·
Tax
dodging. Illegal methods to avoid paying taxes
·
Stake out:
Watch a location to identify who comes and goes
·
Juggle
funds: Handle and move money to and from various accounts for dishonest
reasons
·
Put a
shadow on somebody: Covertly follow somebody wherever they go
·
On the
high road: In the easiest possible way
·
Force
one’s hand: Make someone do something
·
Know the
lay of the land. Be familiar with where things (roads, trees, landmarks,
etc.) are located in a place
·
Percolator:
a device for making coffee, consisting of a pot in which boiling water is
circulated through a small chamber that holds the ground beans. If you want to
start a fight, start an argument between people whose use a percolator and
people who use a cone.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WjaXBqJA-bs